Pour Over Jazz
Paul Chambers – Whims of Chambers (Blue Note BLP 1534)

Blue Note BLP 1534 · 12-inch LP · 1956

BLP 1534

Whims of Chambers

Paul Chambers

The Pour Over · our notes on BLP 1534

Whims of Chambers

Paul Chambers was 21, and already the bass player everyone wanted. Born in Pittsburgh and raised in Detroit, he came to New York with Paul Quinichette's band, and by 1956 he had spent about a year and a half with Miles Davis. Leonard Feather, in the original notes, places him in the short line of bassists who followed Jimmy Blanton, and calls him the first jazzman known as a soloist both with the bow and with his fingers. Feather calls this Chambers's first Blue Note LP as a leader; a Billboard notice reprinted on The Jazz Tome calls it only his second as a headliner anywhere.

The date was Friday, September 21, 1956, at Rudy Van Gelder's in Hackensack, with Alfred Lion producing. Chambers brought two of his bandmates from the Davis group, John Coltrane on tenor and Philly Joe Jones on drums. Donald Byrd, who had gone to Cass Tech in Detroit like Chambers, played trumpet. Horace Silver played piano, and another Detroiter, Kenny Burrell, guitar. Seven tunes were taped and all seven made the record. Not every tune uses the whole band: the title tune leaves out the horns, "Dear Ann" leaves out Coltrane, and "Tale of the Fingers" is a trio.

Side one opens with Byrd's "Omicron," which has an introduction and a coda in 6/8 and a plucked solo from the leader. "Whims of Chambers" is a blues, with bass and guitar playing the line an octave apart. Coltrane wrote "Nita," and Feather singles out Jones's drum solo.

Side two starts with "We Six," a minor theme by Byrd, where Chambers solos with the bow before Burrell and Silver. "Dear Ann" is named for his wife. Feather's favorite was the trio piece, built on the chords of "Strike Up the Band":

it opens with four choruses of bowed bass, and never before have there been 128 measures even remotely like this.

Leonard Feather, original liner notes

The record closes with Coltrane's "Just for the Love," on which all six players take a turn.

Wikipedia credits the sleeve to Reid Miles, with photography by Francis Wolff.

The record was out by January 1957, when Billboard reviewed it. Much later, Scott Yanow at AllMusic wrote that it would be worth having even without Coltrane on it. Two months after this date Chambers was back at Van Gelder's, on bass for Hank Mobley's sextet.

Sources: Leonard Feather, original liner notes, Blue Note BLP 1534 (1957) · Wikipedia, "Whims of Chambers" · Jazz Discography Project (jazzdisco.org), Blue Note 1500 series, BLP 1534

Released
January 1957
Tracks
7
Original notes
Leonard Feather

The sources disagree on the year: 1956 in the Jazz Discography Project, 1957 on Wikipedia.

Who's on it

Credits

Producer
Alfred Lion
recording engineer
Rudy Van Gelder
design
Reid Miles
photography
Francis Wolff
liner notes
Leonard Feather

The tracks

Side one

  1. 1OmicronDonald ByrdSeptember 21, 1956 · take 57:21
  2. 2Whims Of ChambersQuartet: Paul Chambers, Kenny Burrell, Horace Silver, Philly Joe JonesSeptember 21, 1956 · take 84:06
  3. 3NitaJohn ColtraneSeptember 21, 1956 · take 96:34

Side two

  1. 1We SixByrdSeptember 21, 1956 · take 37:42
  2. 2Dear AnnQuintet: Paul Chambers, Donald Byrd, Kenny Burrell, Horace Silver, Philly Joe JonesSeptember 21, 1956 · take 134:21
  3. 3Tale Of The FingersTrio: Paul Chambers, Horace Silver, Philly Joe JonesSeptember 21, 1956 · take 64:44
  4. 4Just For The LoveColtraneSeptember 21, 1956 · take 113:43

Together elsewhere

The other albums at least two of these players are on together.

3 of them 3 albums

No.TitleLeaderYearWho
BLP 1540Hank Mobley with Donald Byrd and Lee MorganHank Mobley1957Paul Chambers, Donald Byrd, Horace Silver
BLP 1577Blue TrainJohn Coltrane1957Paul Chambers, John Coltrane, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 1576Sonny's CribSonny Clark1958Paul Chambers, Donald Byrd, John Coltrane

2 of them 21 albums

No.TitleLeaderYearWho
BLP 5070The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson Vol. 3 · not on the site yetJay Jay Johnson Quintet1955Paul Chambers, Horace Silver
BLP 1506The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson Volume 2J.J. Johnson1956Paul Chambers, Horace Silver
BLP 1523Introducing Kenny BurrellKenny Burrell1956Paul Chambers, Kenny Burrell
BLP 1536J.R. MonteroseJ.R. Monterose1956Horace Silver, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 1538Lee Morgan Indeed!Lee Morgan1956Horace Silver, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 15396 Pieces of SilverHorace Silver1956Donald Byrd, Horace Silver
BLP 4325Horace Silver Quintet · not on the site yetHorace Silver Quintet1956Donald Byrd, Horace Silver
BLP 1541Lee Morgan Sextet (Vol. 2)Lee Morgan1957Paul Chambers, Horace Silver
BLP 1543Kenny Burrell Volume 2Kenny Burrell1957Paul Chambers, Kenny Burrell
BLP 1558Sonny Rollins Volume 2Sonny Rollins1957Paul Chambers, Horace Silver
BLP 1559A Blowing SessionJohnny Griffin1957Paul Chambers, John Coltrane
BLP 1560HankHank Mobley1957Donald Byrd, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 1569Bass on TopPaul Chambers1957Paul Chambers, Kenny Burrell
BLP 1573John Jenkins with Kenny BurrellJohn Jenkins1957Paul Chambers, Kenny Burrell
BLP 1578The CookerLee Morgan1957Paul Chambers, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 1564Paul Chambers QuintetPaul Chambers1958Paul Chambers, Donald Byrd
BLP 1579Sonny Clark TrioSonny Clark1958Paul Chambers, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 1588Cool Struttin'Sonny Clark1958Paul Chambers, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 4200Jimmy Smith Trio · not on the site yetJimmy Smith Trio1958Kenny Burrell, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 4004Holiday For Skins Volume 1 · not on the site yetArt Blakey1959Donald Byrd, Philly Joe Jones
BLP 4005Holiday For Skins Volume 2 · not on the site yetArt Blakey1959Donald Byrd, Philly Joe Jones
Sources

Jazz Discography Project (sessions, takes, personnel) · Wikipedia (release, running order, credits) · Discogs · MusicBrainz · AllMusic · Wikidata · Leonard Feather, original liner notes (read for our notes)

In the Modern Jazz 1500 series